Carpal Tunnel SyndromeHistory of the Procedure: Sir James Paget first
reported median nerve compression at the wrist following a distal radius
fracture in 1854. In 1880, James Putnam presented the first series of
patients with pain and paresthesias in the median nerve distribution of
the hand. In 1913, Pierre Marie and Charles Foix described the pathology
of median nerve compression underneath the transverse carpal ligament
(TCL). In 1933, Sir James Learmonth reported the first TCL release to
treat median nerve compression at the wrist. Since these early reports,
much work has described the signs and symptoms of CTS as well as its
treatments.
Frequency: CTS is common in the general population.
CTS previously has been reported with acute onset following trauma to the
wrist or as a gradual progression of symptoms typically occurring in women
who are in the late middle-aged years of life. More recently, a new
population at risk has been reported to be industrial workers, whose hands
and wrists are subjected to repetitive motion and trauma.
Controversy exists regarding the clinical and electrophysiologic
findings necessary to diagnose CTS. Despite this controversy, several
surveys have been conducted to determine the prevalence of CTS in the
general population. In the Netherlands, the prevalence of undetected CTS
was 5.8% in women and 0.6% in men. In Sweden, the overall prevalence of
CTS in the population was 2.7%. These prevalence rates were based both on
clinical and electrophysiologic criteria and probably represent minimum
prevalence rate estimates.
Etiology: The etiology of CTS is multifactorial, with
both local and systemic factors contributing to varying degrees. Symptoms
of CTS are a result of median nerve compression at the wrist, with
ischemia and impaired axonal transport of the median nerve across the
wrist. Compression results from elevated pressures within the carpal
canal. Elevated pressures can develop within the carpal canal despite it
not being a separate closed compartment within the upper extremity. Direct
pressure or a space-occupying lesion within the carpal canal can increase
pressure on the median nerve and produce CTS. Fracture callus,
osteophytes, anomalous muscle bodies, tumors, hypertrophic synovium, gout
and other inflammatory conditions, and infection can produce increased
pressure within the carpal canal. Extremes of wrist flexion and extension
also elevate pressure within the carpal canal.
Compression of a nerve affects intraneural blood flow. Pressures as low
as 20-30 mm Hg retard venular blood flow in a nerve. Axonal transport is
impaired at 30 mm Hg. Neurophysiologic changes manifested as sensory and
motor dysfunction are present at 40 mm Hg. Further increases in pressure
produce increasing sensory and motor block. At 60-80 mm Hg, complete
cessation of intraneural blood flow is observed. The carpal canal
pressures in patients with CTS averaged 32 mm Hg compared to only 2 mm Hg
in control subjects.
Pressure on the median nerve at a second site remote from the wrist,
termed the double crush syndrome, can further lower the median nerve’s
pressure threshold for producing symptoms of CTS. If a nerve is compressed
at multiple sites, traction within the nerve with joint motion may be
produced. In addition to pressure, traction or stretch has been
demonstrated to produce alterations in intraneural circulation. Elongation
of only 8% can impair venular flow, and all intraneural microcirculation
can cease at 15% nerve elongation.
Many systemic conditions are strongly associated with CTS. These
conditions may directly or indirectly affect microcirculation, pressure
thresholds for nerve conduction, nerve cell body synthesis, and axon
transport or interstitial fluid pressures. Perturbations in the endocrine
system, as observed in individuals with diabetes and hypothyroidism and in
women who are pregnant, are linked to CTS. Conditions affecting metabolism
(eg, alcoholism, renal failure with hemodialysis, mucopolysaccharidoses)
also are associated with CTS.
The international debate regarding the relationship between CTS and
repetitive motion and work is ongoing. The Occupational Safety and Health
Administration (OSHA) has adopted rules and regulations regarding
cumulative trauma disorders. Occupational risk factors of repetitive
tasks, force, posture, and vibration have been cited. However, the
American Society for Surgery of the Hand has issued a statement that the
current literature does not support a causal relationship between specific
work activities and the development of diseases such as CTS.
Psychosocial and socioeconomic issues increasingly are being studied.
In a study of risk factors for CTS in women, the strongest link was a
previous history of another musculoskeletal complaint. Perceptions of
health and tolerance to pain also may influence the development of CTS.
Pathophysiology: The pathophysiology of CTS typically
is demyelination. In more severe cases, secondary axonal loss may be
present. The most consistent findings of biopsy specimens of tenosynovium
in patients undergoing surgery for idiopathic CTS have been vascular
sclerosis and edema. Localized amyloid deposition in the tenosynovium also
has been reported in persons with idiopathic CTS. Inflammation,
specifically tenosynovitis, is not part of the pathophysiologic process in
chronic idiopathic CTS.
Clinical: Acute CTS can develop following a major
trauma to the upper extremity (typically a distal radius fracture), a
carpal dislocation, or a crush injury. Swelling, pain, and paresthesias in
the median nerve distribution of the hand (palmar and radial) are
observed.
In the more common idiopathic or chronic CTS, symptoms are more gradual
in onset. Pain and paresthesias in the median nerve distribution of the
hand are common. Symptoms often are worse at night and can wake a patient
from sleep. As the condition worsens, daytime paresthesias become common
and often are aggravated by daily activities like driving, holding a book
or the phone, and combing the hair. Weakness can be present. With
long-standing or severe cases of CTS, thenar atrophy frequently is
observed. Because of the motor and sensory disturbances, manual dexterity
is diminished, and difficulty with daily activities (eg, buttoning
clothes, holding small objects) often is encountered. Pain and
paresthesias also can occur proximally in the forearm, elbow, shoulder,
and neck in up to one third of patients. Pain and paresthesias in the hand
are not always isolated to median nerve distribution but can involve the
ulnar aspect or the entire hand.
Chronic CTS presents over time and is treated in both an operative and
nonoperative fashion. Patients with milder symptoms and shorter nerve
conduction delays on electrodiagnostic studies respond most favorably to
nonoperative treatments. Patients with more severe symptoms of duration
longer than one year, weakness, atrophy, radial-sided hand numbness,
2-point discrimination greater than 6 mm, and longer nerve conduction
delays often do not benefit from nonoperative care. Failure or findings
predictive of failure of nonoperative treatment are indications for
surgical treatment of CTS.
Relevant
Anatomy: The carpal canal is a fibroosseous tunnel at the wrist
through which 9 flexor tendons and the median nerve pass. The carpal bones
define the dorsal aspect of the carpal canal and are shaped in a concave
arch. The palmar aspect of the carpal canal is defined by the TCL, which
bridges from one side of the carpal arch to the other. Both intrinsic and
extrinsic ligaments of the wrist and hand further stabilize the carpal
bones. The carpal canal is narrowest at the level of the hook of the
hamate, where the canal averages 20 mm in width.
The TCL attaches to the scaphoid tuberosity and trapezial crest on the
radial side of the wrist and to the pisiform and hook of the hamate on the
ulnar side of the wrist (see Image
1). The TCL is 1.5 mm thick and 21.7 mm in length on average.
Proximally, the TCL is a continuation of the antebrachial fascia in the
forearm, and, distally, the TCL attaches to the fibers of the midpalmar
fascia. The TCL is under tension and helps to maintain the carpal arch. It
serves as a retinacular pulley for the flexor tendons. Cutting the TCL
increases the volume of the carpal canal. Cutting the TCL has also been
postulated to alter the kinematics of the carpus, risk bowstringing of the
flexor tendons, and decrease grip strength.
A combination of the lateral (C6-7) and medial (C8-T1) cords of the
brachial plexus forms the median nerve. At the wrist and into the palm,
the median nerve divides into terminal motor and sensory branches with
some anatomic variability. The variability is due in part to the branching
point of the recurrent motor branch. An extraligamentous pattern, with a
branching point distal to the TCL, is the most common. The recurrent motor
branch also can divide from the median nerve underneath the TCL in a
subligamentous fashion and then either wrap around the distal end of the
TCL or pass directly through the TCL to innervate the thenar muscles.
Other less common patterns, such as a branch point proximal to the TCL,
exist as well. These variations can have major surgical implications.
The ulnar nerve is the other major motor and sensory nerve of the hand.
The ulnar nerve does not pass through the carpal canal but instead through
the Guyon canal located adjacent to the carpal canal at the wrist.
Division of the TCL will change the morphology of the Guyon canal from
triangular to ovoid.
Contraindications: No specific contraindications exist
for surgical treatment of CTS. Medical conditions should be stabilized
prior to surgery. Pregnancy should be allowed to proceed to term, as CTS
often resolves after the pregnancy. Unrealistic expectations can influence
surgical outcomes, and risk factors for poor outcomes should be sought
preoperatively. Those individuals with severe CTS should be cautioned that
their numbness may persist, at least to some degree, despite a complete
surgical release. Patients receiving worker's compensation have a lower
return-to-work rate. Higher preference for improved strength
preoperatively also has been associated with lower satisfaction.
Imaging Studies: Other Tests: Diagnostic Procedures:
Surgical therapy: Open and endoscopic surgical
techniques have been described for treatment of CTS. Both operative
techniques are effective for the treatment of chronic CTS. Potential
benefits of the endoscopic technique, including a more rapid functional
recovery, have to be weighed against the increased cost and higher
complication rate of the endoscopic technique. Reliability and good
visualization of the open technique continue to make it the preferred
operation for many hand surgeons. Both techniques are described below.
Open release with an extended surgical incision is recommended for acute
CTS.
Intraoperative details: Open carpal tunnel release
General, regional, or local anesthesia can be used. Surgery is
performed with a tourniquet inflated around the arm to control bleeding in
the operative field.
Postoperative splinting has been recommended to prevent prolapse of
nerve, entrapment of nerve in scar tissue, or tendon bowstringing.
However, splinting has not been demonstrated to have any beneficial effect
and can increase pain and scar tenderness.
Endoscopic carpal tunnel release
One- and 2-incision (ie, portal) techniques are described.
In both the 1- and 2-incision techniques, if visualization is not
satisfactory, the technique should be abandoned and converted to an open
carpal tunnel release.
NEW FINDINGS Dr. Annette A. M. Gerritsen from Vrije Universiteit Medical Center,
Amsterdam, and colleagues randomly assigned 176 patients with idiopathic
carpal tunnel syndrome to open carpal tunnel release surgery or at least 6
weeks of nighttime wrist splinting.
During 18 months of follow-up, the researchers evaluated overall
improvement, severity of symptoms and the number of nights when symptoms
caused the patient to wake up. Treatment success was defined as a general
improvement score by the patient of "completely recovered" or
"much improved."
Intention-to-treat analysis found that those allocated to open carpal
tunnel release surgery had better outcomes on all measures compared with
patients allocated to splinting.
At 3 months, 80% of the patients in the surgery group reported
treatment success, compared with 54% of the patients in the splint group
(p < 0.001).
After 18 months, treatment was successful for 90% of the 68 patients in
the surgery group who could be evaluated, compared with 75% of the 79
patients in the splint group (p=0.02). However, Dr. Gerritsen's group
notes that by 18 months, 41% of the patients (n=32) in the splint group
had undergone open carpal tunnel release surgery.
In an additional analysis, after 18 months, surgery was successful in
94% of the 32 patients in the splint group who underwent surgery, whereas
splinting was successful in 62% of the remaining 47 patients who did not
undergo surgery.
"The study by Gerritsen et al. strongly reinforces findings that
indicate splinting is an excellent adjunctive treatment in early cases,
but is ineffective on a long-term basis for treating this condition
[carpal tunnel syndrome]," Dr. E. F. Shaw Wilgis from Union Memorial
Hospital, Baltimore, comments in an accompanying editorial.
"The findings of Gerritsen et al. also suggest that there is no
need for patients with carpal tunnel syndrome to continue to have pain,
functional limitations, or sleep loss when surgery produces such a
favorable outcome," Dr. Wilgis adds.
Incomplete release of the TCL is reported to be the most common
complication of endoscopic carpal tunnel release. Loss of grip strength
and tenderness of scars following open carpal tunnel release tend to
resolve with time.
The general consensus among surgeons is that nerve injuries occur with
greater frequency with an endoscopic method than with an open release.
Nerve injuries with the endoscopic technique are not necessarily related
to the skill and experience of the surgeon but may be related to the
nature of the procedure, the anatomy of the carpal canal, and the device
used.
OUTCOME AND PROGNOSIS
Lasting relief of pain,
numbness, and paresthesias can be expected in more than 90% of patients
treated with open or endoscopic carpal tunnel release, and patient
satisfaction is high. The endoscopic technique is associated with a
shorter interval to return to work and less incisional pain. The primary
reason for a poor result is an error in diagnosis.
FUTURE AND CONTROVERSIES
The etiology of CTS and its
relationship to the workplace will continue to be better understood in the
coming decades. It already is apparent that the etiology of CTS is
multifactorial, and while work-induced repetitive trauma may not be the
major cause of CTS, it may contribute in some way.
A realized goal of the less invasive endoscopic technique is to return
individuals to work sooner. Presently, concerns over safety and cost have
prevented current endoscopic techniques from being widely accepted and
used. In the future, safer endoscopic techniques and new less invasive or
nonoperative techniques to provide safe and lasting treatment for CTS
hopefully will be developed.
IMAGES
Caption: Picture 1. Cross sections of the carpal canal at the levels of the
proximal and distal carpal rows are depicted. The transverse carpal
ligament bridges the carpal tunnel and is under tension. Caption: Picture 2. Surgical incision for an open carpal tunnel release is
depicted. The incision can be extended proximally across the wrist
flexion crease for a more extended exposure. Caption: Picture 3. Surgical incisions for an endoscopic (1 and 2 portal)
carpal tunnel release are depicted. Precise location of the
incisions is critical and depends on individual anatomy. REFERENCES
MEDCEU
Continuing Education Courses CEU for Nurses and Healthcare Professional
|